Hunter & Thief

Hunter & Thief brings serious cocktail craft to Long Island with a moody, Manhattan-inspired atmosphere that feels worlds away from typical suburban bars. The long bar anchors an intimate space where dim lighting and sophisticated decor set the stage for Dutch Kill Old Fashioneds and a deep menu of classics and creative house builds. It gets loud when busy, but the quality of what's in your glass—and the clear passion behind the program—makes it worth the trip. This is the owners' love letter to NYC cocktail culture and their Long Island roots, and both influences show.