The High Horse

This 25+ upscale cocktail bar sits above Dark Horse Tavern, giving downtown Farmingdale a rare second-story nightlife destination with sweeping village views. Since opening in 2022, it's drawn a more mature crowd looking to escape the street-level pub scene for craft cocktails and elevated conversation. The age policy filters the energy just right—sophisticated without being stuffy, grown-up without being pretentious. Friday and Saturday nights bring DJ programming that keeps things lively without drowning out your date.