Island Mermaid

This dockside Fire Island institution centers waterfront dining but transforms into a lively nightlife destination after sunset. Located right on the Great South Bay in Ocean Beach's core, the casual-elegant space draws a mix of weekenders and locals for craft cocktails at the bar, dancing after dinner, and live music events throughout the season. The open-air setting and bay breezes create that classic Fire Island energy—dressed up enough to feel special, relaxed enough to settle in for hours.