CJ's

A Fire Island institution since 1971, CJ's is the laid-back Ocean Beach bar where generations have gathered for frozen Rocket Fuels—a boozy piña colada spiked with Bacardi 151 that's blended by a dedicated team year-round. The vibe is pure beachside casual: music rocking, drinks flowing, and a crowd that ranges from sunburned day-trippers to locals who've been coming since Gio opened the place. It's the kind of spot where you settle in after a beach day, order lobster specials at prices that defy Fire Island inflation, and let a few Rocket Fuels turn into a full night out.