Wantagh Inn

A beloved Wantagh institution since 1984, this Irish tavern sits across from the train station and delivers exactly what Long Island locals want: reliably good pub fare, a lively bar scene on weekends, and what they claim is the best 20oz pint of Guinness on the island. The active bar area buzzes with neighborhood regulars, while the dining room handles everything from last-minute parties of 12 to casual weeknight dinners. It's that rare suburban spot that functions equally well as your Friday night destination and your reliable go-to.