Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub

This old-world Irish pub on Bay Shore's Main Street delivers authentic comfort in a relaxed, soft-lit setting. The bar pours proper Guinness and Smithwick's alongside fresh craft taps, while the kitchen turns out satisfying plates of fish and chips, shepherd's pie, and hearty pub fare. Live music brings energy to the large, charming space, and the friendly bartenders keep regulars and newcomers equally at ease. It's the kind of neighborhood gem where the taps are always fresh and the atmosphere stays welcoming.