Mary Carroll’s

This Irish pub in Babylon Village has grown from a 1997 fixer-upper into a sprawling neighborhood institution with serious whiskey credentials—150 bottles strong, the largest collection on Long Island. Owner Conor Hartnett's 25-year vision includes a year-round covered patio, 19 beers on draught, and murals by local artist Theresa Christensen. The gastro pub menu runs until the late hours with serious plates like Irish spice bags and burrata flatbreads. It's the kind of place where regulars at the bar know your name, but newcomers get the Irish welcome—live and let live, with occasional live music and a seasonal pop-up beach.